Total = 36

2024:

T'iar Young (Honorable Mention)

2023:

Chris Collier (1st team AFCA)

2018:

Jalen Jackson (2nd team AFCA)

2017:

Kevin Chapple (Honorable Mention)

Trent Fielding (Honorable Mention)

2015:

Shawn Seif (3rd Team Little America)

2003:

Rob Carey

2002:

Rob Carey

Derek Metz

1999:

Jason Kundtz

1992:

Larry Walker

Ken Walker

1988:

Scott Govern

1989:

Scott Govern

1982:

Mike Kresovich (Honorable Mention Little) 

1980:

Joe Speese (Honorable Mention Little)

Scott Reiner (Honorable Mention Little)

1979:

Joe Speese (Honorable Mention Little)

1978:

Joe Speese (Honorable Mention Little)

1976:

Charlie Lucas (Honorable Mention Little)

1971:

Mike Packer (Honorable Mention Little)

1964

Bob Gutshall

1961:

William Kahler

Fred Peightal (Honorable Mention Little)

Jerry Roberts (Honorable Mention Little)

1960: 

Ron Puhl (Honorable Mention Little)

Ron Pul (First Team NAIA)

Bob Doan (Honorable Mention Little)

Fran Cornelius (Second Team NAIA)

Jerry Roberts (Honorable Mention Little)

Fred Peightal

1958:

Robert Difonzo (Honorable Mention Little)

Richard Deibert (Honorable Mention Little)

1957: 

Carmen Letto

Richard Conner

1945: 

Robert Eyer (First Team Little)

2024:

T'iar Young - 1st Team

2023:

Chris Collier - 2nd Team

2019:

Chantz Swartz - 2nd Team

2018:

Jalen Jackson - 1st Team

Obadiah Asare - 3rd Team

Dontae Mason - 3rd Team

Nysir Minney-Gratz - 3rd Team

2017:

Trent Fielding - 3rd Team

Isaiah Flamer - 3rd Team

2016:

Del'Vaughn Dennis - 1st Team

Shawn Seif - 2nd Team

Caleb Walton - 2nd Team

Trent Fielding - 2nd Team

Kevin Chapple - 3rd Team

2015:

Tony Ballon - 2nd Team

Del'Vaughn Dennis - 3rd Team

Luke Erdman - 3rd Team

2012:

Skyler Wool - 3rd Team

*Since 2010 (Records incomplete)

Total = 250

PSAC ROY - 2X

PSAC COY - 1X

2024

First Team PSAC

T'iar Young

Chris Hicks

Second Team PSAC

Edward Leak

2023

First Team PSAC

Chris Collier

Cody Romano

Second Team PSAC

Joe Turek

Kasir Henry

2021

Second Team PSAC

Shane Scott

Anthony Barber

2019

Second Team PSAC

Chantz Swartz

Trevor Miller

2018

First Team

Jalen Jackson

Obadiah Asare

Nysir Minney-Graztz

Second Team 

Chantz Swartz 

David Statton

Bryan Greene

Dontae Mason

2017

First Team

Trent Fielding

Isaiah Flamer

Second Team

Devante Oliver

Carlos Balkcom

Daniel Strawbridge

2016

First Team

Caleb Walton

Del’Vaughn Dennis

Shawn Seif

Trent Fielding

Kevin Chapple

Second Team

Isaiah Flamer

Nysir Minney-Gratz

2015

First Team

Luke Erdman

Tony Ballon

Daniel Strawbridge

Second Team

Malyk Harris

Del’Vaughn Dennis

2014

Second Team

George Christas

2013

Second Team

Brandon Brader

James Wilburn

Anthony Herko

Tyrek Morgan

2012

First Team

Skyler Wool 

Second Team

James Goins

Anthony Herko 

2011

Second Team

Brandon Brader

Anthony Herko

Skyler Wool

2010

Second Team

Ryan Gibble 

Nick Gounaris 

2009

Second Team

Nick Gounaris

2008

Second Team

Ryan Gibble

2007

Second Team

Ryan Gibble

2005

First Team

Steve Szobocsan

Second Team

Jeffery Eaton

Derek Marshall

David Show

Brad Sones

2004

First Team

Jarrod Hendricks

Second Team

Rafael Smith 

Maurice Walker

2003

First Team

Rob Carey (DB)

Marcus Burkley

Second Team

Rob Carey (RS)

Rafael Smith

Derrik Metz

2002

Mark Luther*

First Team

Rob Carey (DB)

Rob Carey (RS)

Marcus Burkley

Derrik Metz

Second Team

Jason Popp

Maurice Walker

*PSAC West Coach of the Year

2001 

Maurice Walker*

First Team

Marcus Burkley

Rob Carey (CB)

Second Team

Lloyd Brooks

John Caldwell

Rob Carey (RS)

DePhilip Jackson

Jonathan Miller

*PSAC West Rookie of the Year

2000

First Team

Matt Mapes

Rob Carey

Second Team

Marcus Burkley*

Chris Hileman

*PSAC West Rookie of the Year

1999

First Team

Jason Kundtz

Matt Mapes

Second Team

Basim Grant

Eric Turbolski

Jamie Allen

Angelo Moultair

1998

First Team

Jamie Allen

Matt Hendricks

Second Team

Jermaine Ballard

Jeremy Burkett

Chris Hileman

Albert Jones

Jason Kundtz

Eric Turbolski

1997

First Team

Matt Hendricks

Ben Steinbacher

Second Team

Jeremy Burkett

Sean Fisher

John Gerst

1996

Second Team

Matt Hendricks

Bryan McGinty

Jeff Rembold

Rashid Rogers

1995

Second Team

Bob McLaughlin

Brad Payne

Jon Spinosa

1994

First Team

Julius Scott

Jon Spinosa

Second Team

Dan Howard

Bob McLaughlin

Brad Payne

1993

First Team

David Hogue

Julius Scott

Second Team

Tony Harrison

Dan Howard

Bob McLaughlin

1992

First Team

Dave Hogue

Second Team 

Tony Harrison

Marcus Moten

Sean O’Connor

Steve Wilmot

1991

First Team

Larry Walker

Second Team

Andre Brown

Eric Muldowney

Brooks Poulsen

1990

First Team

John Kling

Sean O’Connor

Second Team

Kenny Walker

1989

First Team

Scott Govern 

Dwayne Tooles

Guy Wade

Second Team

Mike Bosi

Dave Luademan

1988

First Team

Scott Govern

Richard Nurse

Dwayne Tooles

Second Team

Rod Govern

Fritz Sevrain

1987

Second Team

Bryon Comly

Steve Suriano

1986

First Team

Stan Allen

John Eisenhooth

Steve Suriano

Second Team

Bob Bausinger

Roosevelt Brown

Ray Howard

Guy Wade

1985

First Team

Bill Peterson

Second Team

Stan Allen

Roosevelt Brown

Julio Enos

Jim McEachern

Steve Suriano

1984

Second Team

Scott Gantz

Chris Kustanbauter

Bill Peterson

1983

First Team

Mike Kresovich

Chris Kustanaulter

Chris Skaer

Second Team 

Chris Jackson

Todd Johnson

Jere Warner

1982

First Team

Terry Creecraft

Carl Dean

Bruno DeMartile

Mike Kresovich

Brian Sekerak (DE)

Second Team

Bobby Lynn

Dan Miller

Brian Sekerak (P)

1981

First Team

Mike Kresovich

Bobby Lynn

Brian Sekerak (DE)

Brian Sekerak (P)

Tony Tillar

Dave Zielinskie

Second Team

Carl Dean

1980 

First Team

Scott Reiner

Joe Speese

Second Team

Bill Sementelli

Chuck Terek

Jeff Bailey

Bob Narducci

Tony Tillar

Dave Zielinskie

Brian Sekerak (P)

1979

First Team

Jim Dressler

Bobby Lynn

Steve Orsini

Bill Sementelli

Joe Speese

Dave Zielinskie

Dan Spittal

Second Team

Bob Narducci

John White 

Tony Garzione

1978

First Team

Joe Speese

Second Team

Charlie Lucas

Brian Morrow

Bob Narducci

1977

First Team

Joe Brooks

Steve Housler

Second Team

John LaPorta

Charlie Lucas

Willie Manville

Brian Morrow

Bill Semantelli

Dan Spittal

1976

First Team

Charlie Lucas

Second Team

Joe Brooks

Jim Doran

Len Rucci

1975

First Team

Terry Szucs

Second Team

Jim Doran 

Eric Gorzynski

Len Rucci

1974 

Second Team

Jerome Conlon

Dan Engleman

1973

First Team

Mel Abel

Gil Brown

Chuck Vennie

Second Team

Dave Bauer

Greg Day

Frank Geiger

1972

First Team

Chuck Vennie

1971

First Team

John Buckley 

Chuck Vennie

Second Team

Paul Simcoe

1970

First Team

Bill Rhodes

1967

First Team

Jim Blacksmith

1966

First Team

Jim Blacksmith

1965

First Team

Jim Blacksmith

Chris Klinger

1964

First Team

Chris Klinger

Joe Pascale

1960

First Team

Fran Cornelius

Ron Puhl

1959

First Team

Fran Cornelius

1957

First Team

George Dintiman

Fred Caro

Dick Connor

Carmen Leto

1956

First Team

Fred Caro

George Dintiman

Second Team

Bud Berringer

John Czap

1954

Second Team 

Bud Berringer

Tony Tate